The problem with Moleskine notebooks


Let’s get one thing straight: I love my Moleskine notebooks. I’ve tried brand after brand after brand, not really caring about the cost (heck, Moleskines aren’t exactly cheap) but I’ve yet to encounter something that can match them. The one thing I’ve yet to give a go is Field Notes, which I will as soon as I get my shit together and actually order them.

Moleskine notebooks have one serious flaw, however.

Or two, to be precise.

The paper. It might be acid free and awesome to write on, but if you like me love gel pens then it isn’t thick enough. The ink can go through the paper, definitely be seen through, and it will take too long to dry. Annoying, but I’ve learned to live with it, in fact I used to have a thick sheet of paper cut to the size of a page in the notebook which I put between the pages. These days I just don’t give a shit though, so I threw it away.

Which brings me to the real problem: Moleskine notebooks are too damn nice. People, by which I mean me and everyone else with the same stellar taste and thoughts, tend to not want to ruin them. As in don’t write something ugly, mundane or plain boring in them. No shopping list, no scribbled phone numbers, and for heaven’s sake don’t you dare rip a page out!

You know what, that sucks.

Notebooks should be used, that’s what they are there for. This is plain paper, put something on it and turn the page. It doesn’t matter if it is “Buy milk” or the solution to all the problems in the world, just put some ink on the pages. Otherwise they will cry, feel left out, and then that will seep on over to you in the form of the curse of the blank page, starring you and your inability to actually produce anything of value.

Don’t care for your Moleskine notebook, don’t value it too high. Value what’s in it instead, by which I mean to say that you actually need to fill the book’s pages to make it worth anything. Even if it is just your shopping list.

  • trebormints

    So very true, loved this post, bravo

  • http://tdhedengren.com Thord Daniel Hedengren

    Thank you!

  • Me

    i buy them in bulk so they are cheaper (try ebay) , also I usually put stickies or scrap paper on the inside of the last page, i use that for jotting down numbers, groceries, etc, and i can replace it with a fresh post it when it’s done.

    The paper is about the thickest out there. unless you wanted to get the water color version of the book, but that paper has some ‘tooth’ i think.

  • http://onegirlcircus.com Karen

    I love Field Notes.  You can even get them customised for events.  I only like the small ones, though.  The standard Moleskines are still my favorites for clothing design ideas.

  • http://www.tomatsallad.nu chefstomaten

    I love your post but not moleskin note books. They are nice, really nice (I would probably never write anything in them) but they miss a place to store the pen. I need to store the pen in the note book, otherwise it is always gone by the time I need it most. Well, sometimes it is gone anyway. 

    I just to buy really nice note books but the manufacturer has dissappeared so now I have to do with note books from Ordning & Reda. No problem writing in them. 

  • http://tdhedengren.com Thord Daniel Hedengren

    That’s an interesting observation. Me, I always have a bunch of pens with me, but I see your point.

  • minty95

    I agree, where to put the pens…

    I’ve ordered the Moleskine pens with their cap that clips on by the side, they should do the job just nicely as  I have their pencils, same cap but the lead is to soft to write with

  • http://tdhedengren.com Thord Daniel Hedengren

    Do let us know how they work out for you!

  • Gabe

    I so agree with you on second point! I was scared to ruin my monthly agenda and other notebooks…it feels like I have to write something very interesting, otherwise it’d become a waste.

  • Anonymous

    Sure they look really nice and have all that cool factor, but aren’t they a bit to nice? And aren’t they more trendy than useful? I always use a sketchpad and printer papers. Plain papers. Then my work won’t be stuck inside a book, and I can trow away those sketches that I have no use for anymore. Or store them somewhere else. Then I only carry what is important for the time being.

    And the biggest bonus is that it’s easy to scan, and make it digital!

  • Pb0077

    You Can also use the sketchbook that one is the Same only with thicker paper.

    Now Its perfect again ;-)

  • minty95

    Nice post am now trying Leuchtturn1917, they seem to be as well made as moleskines but their pages are slightly heavier, acid free  and they have numbered pages amongst other things. They are cheaper as well :)

    I’ve just added some details to my blog : http://minty95.wordpress.com/2011/08/28/analog-moleskine-am-i-going-back-to-stone-age/

  • http://twitter.com/bstark bstark!

    “Moleskine notebooks are too damn nice”
    You’re bloody spot on there. Have one but almost never use it. It’s like I have to write things down on a regular A4 first and then write it all over in the Moleskine again – better formatted and prettier.

    But I like to have it along then I travel, rarely use it – but still.

    Please report back with your impressions of the Field notes. I might give them a try.

  • http://twitter.com/bstark bstark!

    I brought one of these pen loops by Leuchtturm1917.
    http://www.thepaperie.co.uk/leuchtturm1917-red-pen-loop.html
    It does it’s job.

  • http://tdhedengren.com Thord Daniel Hedengren

    Will do!

  • Pingback: Notebook Stories: A Blog About Notebooks, Journals, Moleskines, Blank Books, Sketchbooks, Diaries and More

  • Rooth

    I used to be so careful with my moleskinea until I saw pictures of others’. They looked battered but loved! Since then I’ve been more careless and it makes me actually fill more pages with writing

  • Deedee396

    Have you tried Hand Book, they make some nice size journals and the paper seems to be thicker.

  • http://tdh.me Thord Daniel Hedengren

    Nope, will have to look into that. Thanks for the tip!

  • http://twitter.com/barryrutherford Barry Rutherford

    I have one and always use pencil !